Does genetic mutation over a long period of time lead to evolution?

One on one, mutations have no purpose and no conscience. They provide brownian motion, if you will, or jitter in the signal. Just the way, 50 years ago, a vibrating piece of sheet metal painted to resemble a football field let six-year-olds play a noisy version of the game, mutations allow populations to drift into adjustment with changing environments etc.

For instance, simple copy errors across SIX BILLION nucleotides (the size of the nuclear DNA in a single human cell) are very very very rare, such that only about fifty mistakes usually occur. This also means that NO TWO cells in anyone’s body will ever have identical DNA. (Go ahead and argue statistics with me – it’s possible, but the odds against are mathematically enormous.)

Mutation dusts tiny bits of fuzz across your DNA, and the bits of fuzz that land on your sperm/egg cell producing organs, which make your germ cells, pass on to your children. Evolution is ab so lute ly un stop pa ble.

When some event separates populations, this inevitable drift, over tens to hundreds of thousands of generations, takes that species from Version One to Versions Two and Three, thus resulting in three distinct species. The same factors that take the two populations past the point of interbreeding successfully have the same effect on either one relative to Version One. (Halfway stations: horses-zebra doesn’t work well, lion-tiger works so-so, and horse-doney makes mules – sturdy, and sterile.)

An opponent of evolution has proposed that, since cows losing their legs can’t make whales, the whole idea is bogus. What’s bogus in such a diminutized dataset is that cows are Version HumtyDumptySeven while whales are many different versions in the series HiggledyPiggledy, of whatever it was that both have derived from. And, by the way, a whale’s skeleton really does have teeny leg bones, and its flippers are basically front legs that grew out flat. That tail the cow swishes? It’s the real motor that drives the whale through the water. Both cows and whales do have tails, y’know.

Genetic mutation is constant. Over long periods of time it’s the engine that makes adaptation and speciation possible.

Forgive the long post – a detail relative to Darwin’s finches on the Galapagos Islands:
They are all the same species; they can all interbreed. Whenever it was that the first breeding pair of finches produced young there, the food sources were numerous. Over time populations specialized. Don’t ask how, the facts on the ground make that outcome obvious.
Each one drifted to do a better job of exploiting a specific food source, and along with functional changes to beaks (etc.) to optimize for that food source, their plumage and song drifted too. The plumage and song changes helped each population stay separate, i.e. to form artificially isolated breeding populations.
Cross-breeding still succeeds, though it is naturally rare. Crossbred progeny don’t survive as well because their beaks (etc.) aren’t well specialized for either parent’s food source.
Why are they still one species? Because they can still interbreed. Why is that? Because there hasn’t been the requisite hundreds of thousands of generations. Someone with the time and interest should be able to compare their DNA and work backwards to how long ago that first pair started things off.
Adam, for instance, lived 70 to 75 thousand years ago; Eve lived 200 to 250 thousand years ago. Implication: Eve was in the same situation as that first mother finch, i.e. of all homo sapiens females, only her daughters survived to carry the line forward. The narrowing-down may have finalized fifty generations after she lived – – – but ONLY HER maternal line went forward. Ditto Adam; only his Y chromosome carried forward. (datapoint: there are a few Y’s in isolated areas of Africa with a 400K year pedigree.)

Novelists in the crowd, make up all the stories you can to dramatize such hard times. Did that Adam carry some Super-Mental gene that organized his gray matter in some devastatingly new manner? Or was he just lucky? Whatever, go for it! Start a new ONE FEMALE SURVIVING / ONE MALE SURVIVING fiction genre. (grins)

2 thoughts on “Does genetic mutation over a long period of time lead to evolution?

  1. Joel, I’m amazed at your obvious error in the timeline between Adam and Eve. Adam came first, so it’s impossible for Eve to be from farther back than he.


  2. (Smiling) Just the facts, Ma’am. GOD said “Let there be light” all right, but that was 13.8 billion years ago. The need to hold up Genesis as either history or science isn’t honoring to our Creator. The stories in Genesis worked very well in the Bronze Age. What makes them GOD’s Word is the theology in them – the ten commandments, the promise of a Savior, the idea of second chances, forgiveness, patience, and love. There are many many Bronze Age “origin stories” and none of them have GOD’s fingerprint, His theology. But all of them, and Genesis is par for the course with regard to its “history” and is “science.” They all disagree, and they all get it wrong. The true part of Genesis is chapter 1 verse 3.
    In the 20th / 21st Centuries we have found a universe screaming its beauty and majesty and glory at us. Genesis describes a planet with lights in the sky that move around. Its vision of earth is majestic, poetic, and beautiful. But in comparison to what we can see today, the beautiful and majestic vision in Genesis is, by comparison, as sock puppet.
    That’s harsh, but on the one hand we have a planet with lights in the sky, and on the other hand we have a universe that is more than three million times the age of the planet described in Genesis, and the main light in the sky, our sun, is something the earth goes around, not the other way around, and it’s a so-so star in the outer arm of one galaxy – while the universe has so many galaxies you’d need about 12 digits to number them. Try 200,000,000,000 to two hundred billion galaxies. Maybe that first digit is a 1, but those eleven zeroes to the right make that kinda moot.
    We really do know that at one point there was a single male line – and on these time scales that could have been a time when fifty or a hundred males of a clan survived a situation that wiped out all other males. War? Climate? Sudden jump in IQ? No way to know – but the amount of genetic diversity in the male Y chromosome can only have accumulated over a period of 60 to 75 thousand years.
    Females share mitochondrial DNA which is sufficiently diverse that the bottleneck, i.e. just one female line from which all homo sapiens alive today have sprung, came along 200 to 250 thousand years ago. Using that as a platform, Adam was Eve’s descendant, but she died several thousand human generations before he was born.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s